The next 2 barrels are a little difficult to see (and hit) thanks to the branches in the way. Take your time and line up your shots. Barrel (2/3) is just beyond the boulder and white birch trees near the pumpkin patch.
Maybe you'll find a better angle, but I was able to sink the shot by standing where Lara is in the previous screenshot and aiming to the right of birch tree as shown here.
The next barrel (3/3) is a little closer to the shelter with the strongbox, behind a spiked log fence.
It took me several tries to get this one thanks to the logs and branches in the way.
The next barrel (4/5) is on the ledge above and behind the strongbox.
For this one, I found it helped to stand fairly close and toss the pumpkin from below. You could also throw the pumpkin onto the roof of the shelter, or onto the ledge, climb up, and toss from there.
The last barrel (5/5) is some distance from the others. Grab a pumpkin and carry it back through the village...
...and around to the back of the first cabin on the right.
The barrel is behind another spiked log fence adjacent to the cabin.
There are no obstructions, so this shot should be fairly easy compared to the others.
When you've made all 5 pumpkin free throws, you'll receive a lovely XP bonus plus 2,000 Expedition Credits if it's your first time beating the challenge.
[Part 1 | Return to the Geothermal Valley Walkthrough]
Copyright © - Stellalune ( ). All rights reserved. Feel free to copy or print this walkthrough for personal use. By all means, share it with friends, but please include this credit line so people can send me their feedback. No part of this walkthrough may be reproduced on another site without permission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Follow this link for details about this site's advertising and privacy policy.